Honoring the Memory
of Those
We Love

Please refer to obituaries for information on visitations, funeral services and requests by the family or deceased for honoring their memory.

Larry James Heenan

April 21, 1945 - November 28, 2025

Text:

Obituary For Larry James Heenan

Age 80, on Friday, November 28, 2025, of Whitehall, formerly of Brentwood, peacefully passed away surrounded by his family.

Beloved husband of 61 years to Judi Heenan ; loving dad of Kevin (Lori) Heenan, Keith (Amy) Heenan, Kim (Karl Sezawich) Shanahan and Kregg (Katie) Heenan; proud pap-pap of Jonathan (Sofia), Sara (Nathan), Ashley (Sam), Adam (Nicole), Alyssa (Brandon), Justin (Sirena), Kelsey (Justin), Matthew, Nico, Gino (Kaitlyn); great grandfather of Jon James, Jane, Henry, Aoife, Samson, Leo, Sahara and Oisin. Also survived by family and friends.

Larry’s life was a story of service. He served with his heart, love and soul to his beautiful wife Judi. Their demonstration of marriage was admired by all who knew them, especially by their four children. After getting married at the age of 19 to his 17 year old bride, he served his young family through learning to cut meat and was known at grocery stores throughout the South Hills. While raising his family, Larry then began serving his community by becoming a volunteer firefighter. Larry served Brentwood for decades as a lifelong member and was incredibly proud of all his roles, especially Chief. But his greatest love of service eventually came behind a counter, serving generations of families….ice cream cones. For 41 years, Larry has brought smiles to people at the place he created, Sugar & Spice Ice Cream Parlor and Cake and Candy Supplies. Sugar & Spice was more than a mom and pop business to him. It was the foundation of Larry’s family and how we all stayed together. Larry knew he would never be rich making milkshakes, the richness came through having a place where the family can work together, gather at, always call home and most importantly work beside Judi every single day. You can say he accomplished that with whipped cream and a cherry on top.

Larry’s motto in life was that “If it requires pants, it’s not happening”, which is why he will be laid to rest in shorts, the same as you would see him every day, year round. And since Larry felt getting dressed up was “pretty dumb”, we ask that everyone dress casually for the viewing and service. Wear your shorts, joggers, leggings, hoodies or Steelers jersey. It will make him smile and you may even hear his "Impractical Jokers viewing laugh" one more time from above.

Life is short, eat dessert first.

Friends will be received at the John F. Slater Funeral Home, Inc., 412-881-4100, 4201 Brownsville Road, Brentwood 15227 on Tuesday, December 2, 2025 from 2-8 p.m. and on Wednesday morning from 9 until time of Blessing Service at 11 a.m. Interment private. In lieu of flowers, donations may be made in Larry’s name to Drop the Puck on Cancer, 301 South Hills Village, Suite LL200 Box 18, Pittsburgh PA 15241 or at www.dropthepuckoncancer.com.

Photos & Video

Add New Photos & Video

Condolences

  • December 13, 2025

    Sharyn Shook

    Judy and Family I'm so sorry of Larrys passing. I'm Sharyn we met in the ICU. Mike was in room 3 Larry one. I knew the day I left on Thursday there were too many family outside and in his room meaning they were saying their goodbyes. Mike and Larry had a lot in common. Mike beside serving in the Airforce 32 years finished as Chief Master Sergent, they both were Fireman. Mike Strauch was Assistant chief for Whitehall as well as Pleasent Hills. We both live in Whitehall as well. I'm really sorry how they both suffered. Mike got out of there and life flighted Dec 1st to AGH. With his health so poor , on Dec 4th we said no more. I know exactly how you feel. This loss is undiscriblable . May they both Rest In Peace, and may our families heal with this terrible loss. Old Boston rd very close neighbors. love to you all.

  • December 02, 2025

    John & Rose Marie Chalovich

    I remember Larry and Judy as youngsters, in love, and with a goal. They made work look like fun! We never tired of their ice cream or of talking to Larry. God rest his soul, he was a lovely man that we will be sorely missed by many.

  • December 01, 2025

    Patrick Cunningham

    To the Heenan Family My sincere condolences to you. Mr Heenan to me was always there when you needed him. Met Him when I used to hang out at the fire hall Always Nice to talk to. He will Be Missed Patrick Cunningham

  • November 30, 2025

    Terry Gross

    Beautiful obit for a true gentleman who was always ready to share a quip, or helping hand, at Sugar & Spice. We will all miss him. So very sorry for your loss of such a dear man.

  • November 29, 2025

    John Busalacchi

    I was introduced to Larry by my Giant Eagle friends and found him to be a very congenial and kind man as we shared several breakfasts together. May God grant peace to his friends and family.

  • November 29, 2025

    Rich Sandstrom ( RMS ServiceS )

    I have known Larry and the whole family for years servicing all of their vehicles. I love how Larry would always call me just to ask a question or for my opinion. I'm truly gonna miss him, he always along with the family have treated me great! My Condolences to the family Larry was such a great man!!!

  • November 29, 2025

    Dave Knoble

    Larry was a best friend, and best man at our wedding. I will never forget him or Judi.

  • November 29, 2025

    Amanda Mettle

    Uncle Larry was always the coolest for me as a kid. I loved going to his icecream parlor and when it was right under mommy's apartment was the best. Never forget when mommom turned 80 and he had a huge party at the shop for her. He made my favorite icecream Grasshopper and always made me and my brother feel welcomed. Miss you lots uncle Larry

  • November 29, 2025

    Kathy Moeslein

    Dear Judi, Kregg and family : We are saddened to learn of Larry's passing. He was one of Brentwood's finest gentlemen! Larry always greeted everyone with a smile ! He loved talking Brentwood sports ,especially basketball , with Mr. Moeslein . I pray all your wonderful memories help you through this difficult time . May you always feel the warmth of his loving arms wrapped around all of you ! RIP our friend Larry💔 Rich , Kathy , Richie, Matt and Janae Moeslein

Skip to content